Home › Food and Drink › Cheese shop
The 10 Best Cheese Shops in Sacramento (2026)
Our 2026 list of the best cheese shops around Sacramento was built from Google reviews using a Bayesian-style approach that balances average rating with review volume. That means places with high scores and meaningful customer feedback rise to the top, while smaller shops with perfect ratings but few reviews are fairly weighted. Sacramento and its surrounding communities have a lively small‑goods scene—ranging from dedicated cheese producers to delis and charcuterie purveyors—so this guide covers nearby towns as well as neighborhoods inside the city to reflect where people actually shop.
This ranking is computed from Google reviews (our method). Listings marked Partner are paid advertising spots: they sit alongside the ranking without changing its order.
Are you a cheese shop in Sacramento?
People reading this page are looking for a pro right now. Put your business above the ranking, with your contact details and a link to your site.
✓ Live immediately · ✓ One-time payment · ✓ No subscription
10 of 10 spots still available
Stuyt Dairy Farmstead Cheese
Stuyt Dairy Farmstead Cheese ranks first thanks to a perfect 5.0 Google rating paired with a substantial 69 reviews, giving it both top marks and solid sampling from customers. Its Google category places it squarely in the cheese world, and the review count helps it outpace smaller shops with perfect scores but fewer reviews. In short, Stuyt’s combination of rating and review volume puts it at the top of our Bayesian-style ranking.
The full ranking
The Dancer’s Pantry
The Dancer’s Pantry holds a 5.0 rating with 55 reviews and appears on Google under Charcuterie, located in Fair Oaks just east of Sacramento.
55 reviews
charQterie
charQterie carries a 4.9 rating based on 241 reviews and is categorized as a Wine bar in Sacramento; its review volume is among the largest on this list.
241 reviews
Fiscalini Cheese Company
Fiscalini Cheese Company shows a 4.9 Google rating from 43 reviews and is listed as a Farm, with its address in Modesto rather than Sacramento proper.
43 reviews
Brie Mine Charcuterie LLC
Brie Mine Charcuterie LLC posts a perfect 5.0 rating with 20 reviews and is categorized as Charcuterie; the business is located in Roseville.
20 reviews
Newcastle Cheese Shop
Newcastle Cheese Shop has a 4.8 rating across 551 reviews, is listed under Sandwich on Google, and is located in Newcastle, north of Sacramento.
551 reviews
Ro Sham Beaux
Ro Sham Beaux carries a 4.8 rating from 198 reviews and is categorized as a Wine bar; its J Street address places it in downtown Sacramento.
198 reviews
Oak Park Bardega
Oak Park Bardega holds a 4.9 rating with 30 reviews and is listed as a Deli, situated in the Oak Park neighborhood of Sacramento.
30 reviews
The New Yorker Deli
The New Yorker Deli is rated 4.8 with 111 reviews, appears under Restaurant on Google, and is located in the Natomas area of Sacramento.
111 reviews
Shaft’s Cheese Co
Shaft’s Cheese Co shows a 5.0 rating from 12 reviews and is categorized as a Cheese manufacturer; the address is in Roseville.
12 reviews
Frequently asked questions
How did you decide which shops made this list?
This ranking is built from Google review data using a Bayesian-style method that weights average rating by the number of reviews. That approach favors businesses with both high scores and a meaningful quantity of feedback, so very small sample sizes don’t unfairly top the list.
What should I look for when choosing a cheese shop?
Check a shop’s selection breadth, the clarity of product labeling, customer reviews, and whether staff can offer guidance or tastings. Proximity, hours, and whether they specialize in local or imported cheeses are also useful considerations.
How much does shopping at a specialty cheese shop typically cost?
Prices vary by cheese type, origin, and aging; expect a range from affordable everyday options to higher-cost artisan and imported varieties. Buying smaller portions or pre-made boards can help manage cost while sampling a few kinds.
When is the best time to call or visit a cheese shop?
Call during regular daytime hours to confirm stock and ask about tastings or platter orders, and visit on weekdays if you prefer less crowding. If you need a platter for a specific event, contact the shop several days in advance to ensure availability.